
Directors: Robert Rodriguez, Quentin Taratino, Edgar Wright, Eli Roth, Rob Zombie
Writers: Robert Rodriguez, Quentin Taratino, Eli Roth, Jeff Rendell
Cast: Naveen Andrews, Michael Biehn, Kurt Russell, Rosario Dawson, Josh Brolin, Vanessa Ferlito, Freddy Rodriguez, Quentin Tarantino
Certificate: 18
Running Time: 189 minutes
Release Date: 06/04/07
Concept: Inspired by dark, dirty movie theatres from the 70s that showed late night exploitation double bills dealing in guns, girls, sex, violence and horror, Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino have produced their own double bill, featuring Rodriguez's 'Planet Terror' and Tarantino's 'Death Proof', and which also includes a number of sleazy, gritty faux-trailerS made by other notable film makers.
Review: AS FAR as concept's go, it's a pretty irresistible prospect for anyone with any interest in film; two of America's hippest directors heading up a bill also featuring talent such as Eli Roth (Cabin Fever, Hostel), Britain's own Edgar Wright (Shaun of the Dead, Hot Fuzz) and the demented Rob Zombie (House of 1000 Corpses).
Most people in the UK wouldn't have directly experienced the 'grind house' in all it's glory, but some will have, at some point, indulged in some intensive viewings of the grimy films that the film makers here are parodying/paying homage to. Part of the enjoyment of these films lies in their faults as well as their strengths. The poor film quality, outrageous violence, gratuitous sex scenes and over-the-top acting, dialogue and storylines all make up the brilliance of the genre. Often the film is more enjoyable the worse it is.
In terms of placing you in the 'grind house', this film succeeds completely. The between-movie infomercial nuances, familiar from Kill Bill 1 and 2, are present and correct once again, and the various film makers assembled perfectly capture the dirty aesthetic of the movies they are based on, complete with all the subtle (and sometimes not so subtle) elements. So much so, that you almost feel like you could be at a late night showing in a movie theatre during the 1970s surrounded by junkies, drunks, transvestites and other general peripheral figures of society, all joined together by a love of all things extreme on celluloid.
The 'fake' trailer are, on the whole, excellent. Edgar Wright's Don't comically riffs on the 'don't-enter-the-cursed-looking-house' scenario of a million horror films, while Eli Roth's brilliant gritty slasher trailer for Thanksgiving is spot on, complete with gore, breasts and great voice over lines full of wry winks and innuendo ("White meat...dark meat...all will be carved..." and "This year there will be...no left overs.") Roth's trailer is so good that for a moment I really thought it was a real film.
The action trailer for Machete also looked good, featuring seasoned 'Mexican-criminal' actor Danny Trejo and Rob Zombie's 'Nazis 'n' chicks' trailer for Werewolf Women of the SS was very entertaining although seemed to be on the edge, or over it, of trying too hard.
But what of the actual films themselves? Onto the main features and first up is Rodriguez's Planet Terror (right). The plot is reasonably non-existent and non-important. What we have is an outbreak of some virus, or chemicals, or chemical virus that turns people into zombies. The people have to fight back, of course, and are lead by hard boiled cop Michael Biehn and rugged drifter Freddy Rodriguez (below, 2nd from left).
It's all really quite mental; Bruce Willis with a melting face, a woman who has her leg amputated and replaces it with a machine gun, a truck smashing and splashing it's way through dozens of zombies, Quentin Tarantino as a grotesque rapist soldier, shootouts, and a deliberately grimy and inappropriately timed sex scene. The acting is purposefully hammed up in places, although there is some nice character and relationship development in between the gory action.
Rodriguez has taken all the elements of the zombie/sci-fi B-movie and turned it up to 11. With better make up and special effects available than the film makers he is inspired by he can let his imagination run riot, hence the machine-gun-attached-to-leg scenario.
The affection for the grindhouse genre is apparent throughout, as is evident through the artificial 'distressing' of the film quality, which enhances the gory atmosphere of the film.
Planet Terror is awesome. With no-holds barred gore, killer one liners, OTT action and hack dialogue. it is both parody and genuinely brilliant zombie film in one bloody package. Everyone in it is clearly having fun, but all play it straight, which adds to the overall effect. It's full of glorious B-movie character stereotypes and plot cliches that take several viewings to completely appreciate.
Following Rodriguez's thumping, pumping, adrenaline and testosterone fuelled effort, what could Tarantino offer up? The answer is; a major disappointment. Even with sugar on top, Death Proof a big let down after the genre genius of Planet Terror.
As Grindhouse is a double bill, the two main films are to be considered separate in their own right. In fact, in many countries Grindhouse will be split and Planet Terror and Death Proof (right) will be released separately. Considering this then, Death Proof is easily Tarantino's worst film to date.
The 'plot' revolves around a character called Stuntman Mike (Kurt Russell, below left), a psycho who likes to kill people using his 'death proof' car. He charms women and offers them a lift home. Then he kills them. Other times he follows groups of women and terrorises them. With the hope of killing them. Which is all well and good, but that's all that happens. In short, Death Proof has a concept but no story.
Tarantino's biggest ace has always been his sharp, snappy, Madonna-and-cheeseburger pop culture referencing dialogue. And there's talking in Death Proof. A lot of talking. But it's not snappy. It's not sharp. And it's not about Madonna. Actually, it's not really about anything. It's totally, utterly boring. In fact, at one point we get treated to a ten minute single take when a group of characters natter on about topics so dull the people I was watching the film with started up their own conversations. Seriously - ten minutes. With nothing happening. It was like watching a new Gus Van Sant movie.
Tarantino broke some rules with Resevoir Dogs. He made many people realise you can have dialogue in a film that doesn't merely provide exposition, move the plot along or develop characters according to a formula. Dialogue can be quirky, trivial and seemingly irrelevant. But you can only do that if the dialogue is interesting and/or amusing. In this respect, Death Proof fails, and Tarantino gets lost in a vortex of banality.
I honestly am not sure what Tarantino is trying to do here. He has simply reproduced a bad B-movie psycho-stalker film. It's boring and bereft of any real humour, drama, suspense or excitement. You keep waiting for it to change into a higher gear, but it never does. Occasionally a scene holds your interest, such as when we are introduced to Stuntman Mike, but otherwise it's a long drawn out experiment in tedium.
At one point during Death Proof QT himself pops up in a bar, as does E
li Roth. They're both laughing and drinking, and one gets the feeling Tarantino is having more fun than the audience.
Death Proof smacks of being a whimsical idea or joke that went too far, a prank on the viewer. Perhaps Tarantino is being too clever for us all, trying to lull us into a false sense of security with dull dialogue before shocking us with sudden violent moments. Perhaps. If that's the case it's so self-indulgent it's practically masturbation.
Undoubtedly, Death Proof will suffer from 'Broken Flowers syndrome', where fans love the director and actors involved so much they're too scared to consider the film objectively, and end up praising it even though it's a poor offering. Just like Broken Flowers, Death Proof leaves you wondering, 'What was the point?'
The credit 'A Film by Quentin Tarantino' still elicits excitement, but one feels that, taken into account along with the Kill Bill films, Quentin Tarantino has lost his way as a visionary writer and director and is now simply regurgitating his cinematic influences and passions rather than making his films his own. While his friend and collaborator Robert Rodriquez goes from strength to strength with films such as Planet Terror and Sin City, Tarantino is dangerously close to becoming a film maker living off his reputation















